Common Mistakes When Searching for a Handyman

Finding the right handyman can feel overwhelming, especially when you're dealing with an urgent repair or a long list of home projects. Unfortunately, many homeowners make critical mistakes during their search that can lead to poor results, wasted money, or even safety hazards.

In this guide, we'll cover the most common mistakes people make when searching for a handyman—and how you can avoid them to ensure a successful home repair experience.

1. Choosing Based on Price Alone

One of the biggest mistakes is selecting the cheapest option without considering other factors. While budget matters, the lowest bid often means:

• Lack of proper insurance or licensing
• Cutting corners on materials or workmanship
• Hidden fees that appear after the job starts
• Inexperienced workers who may cause more damage

What to do instead: Get at least three quotes and compare what's included. Look for value, not just the lowest number. A slightly higher price often means better quality, proper insurance, and peace of mind.

2. Not Checking Reviews and References

Many homeowners skip the crucial step of checking a handyman's reputation. Online reviews and references from past customers give you insight into:

• Quality of work
• Punctuality and professionalism
• How they handle problems
• Communication style

What to do instead: Read reviews on multiple platforms (Google, Yelp, BBB). Ask the handyman for references and actually call them. Look for patterns in feedback—one bad review isn't concerning, but consistent complaints are a red flag.

3. Skipping the Licensing and Insurance Check

Hiring an unlicensed or uninsured handyman can expose you to serious liability. If a worker gets injured on your property or causes damage, you could be financially responsible.

What to do instead: Always verify that your handyman has:

• A valid business license (requirements vary by state)
• General liability insurance
• Workers' compensation insurance (if they have employees)

4. Not Getting Everything in Writing

Verbal agreements lead to misunderstandings about scope, pricing, and timeline. Without a written contract, you have no protection if things go wrong.

What to do instead: Insist on a written estimate or contract that includes:

• Detailed description of the work
• Materials to be used
• Total cost and payment schedule
• Start and completion dates
• Warranty information

5. Ignoring Communication Red Flags

How a handyman communicates before the job often indicates how they'll perform during it. Warning signs include:

• Not returning calls or texts promptly
• Being vague about pricing or scope
• Pressuring you to make quick decisions
• Unwillingness to answer questions

What to do instead: Choose someone who communicates clearly, answers your questions thoroughly, and makes you feel comfortable. Trust your instincts.

6. Paying Too Much Upfront

Some dishonest contractors take large deposits and disappear. While a small deposit is reasonable, paying too much before work begins is risky.

What to do instead: A reasonable deposit is typically 10-30% of the total job cost. Pay in installments tied to project milestones. Never pay in full before the work is completed to your satisfaction.

7. Hiring Someone Without Meeting Them First

You're inviting this person into your home. Hiring based solely on a phone call or online profile means you miss important cues about their professionalism and trustworthiness.

What to do instead: Schedule an in-person meeting or estimate visit before hiring. This allows you to:

• Assess their professionalism
• Get an accurate quote (they can see the actual work needed)
• Ask questions face-to-face
• Trust your gut about whether they're the right fit

8. Not Defining the Scope Clearly

Vague instructions lead to disappointing results. If you're not specific about what you want, you might not get what you envisioned.

What to do instead: Be as detailed as possible about:

• Exactly what needs to be done
• Materials and finishes you prefer
• Any existing issues they should know about
• Your expectations for cleanup and disposal

Find the Right Handyman with Confidence

By avoiding these common mistakes, you'll be much more likely to find a reliable, skilled handyman who delivers quality work at a fair price. Remember: a little extra effort in the search process saves you time, money, and stress in the long run.

Ready to find vetted, professional handymen in your area? Get free quotes from licensed pros near you and compare your options with confidence.